Great Taste and Old Fashioned Quality
NEW Gourmet
Cheese Spread
Contact Us
Great Taste and Old Fashioned Quality
SNACK STICKS
Contact Us
Great Taste and Old Fashioned Quality
CHEESE SPREAD
Contact Us

Family Owned & Operated

Why Choose Us

Old Fashioned Cheese is a family owned and operated company, dedicated to “Great Taste and Old Fashioned Quality”. Located in Mayville, Wisconsin, the heart of America’s Dairyland, the company is dedicated to crafting delicious and nutritious natural cheese snacks and spreads. We’re cheeseheads through and through, and proud of it!

LEARN MORE

Great Taste,
Old Fashioned Quality

Good, and good for you!

Old Fashioned Cheese is a family owned and operated company, dedicated to “Great Taste and Old Fashioned Quality”. Located in Mayville, Wisconsin, the heart of America’s Dairyland, the company is dedicated to crafting delicious and nutritious natural cheese snacks and spreads. We’re cheeseheads through and through, and proud of it!

WHY US

A History Of Quality

Choose Your Favorite Product
cheese-spread-shot

GOURMET CHEESE SPREADS

New from the people who bring you America’s best-tasting classic cold pack cheese spreads…Old Fashioned Gourmet.
Learn More
Old Fashioned Cheese Cheese Spread

CLASSIC CHEESE SPREAD

Creamy and spreadable in 8 oz and 14 oz containers, you have the option to choose from nine great flavors.
Learn More
Old Fashioned Cheese Cheese Ball

CHEESE BALLS

The perfect hors d’oeuvre made with our popular spreadable cheddar cheese and covered with premium almonds.
Learn More
Old Fashioned Cheese Snack Sticks and Sandwich

CHEESE SNACK STICKS

Our Natural Cheese Snack Sticks are the perfect solution for snacking wherever and whenever! Readily available in your refrigerator.
Learn More
sandwhich-snack-sticks-meat

CHEESE & MEAT STICKS

Old Fashioned Cheese & Meat Snack Sticks are the ultimate duo providing the best of both worlds.
Learn More
Old Fashioned Cheese Cheese Trios

CHEESE TRIOS

Healthy snacking in an instant, Cheese Trios combine all natural cheddar cheese available in three delicious combos.
Learn More

NEW From Old Fashioned Cheese

GOURMET CHEESE SPREADS
New from the people who bring you America’s best-tasting classic cold pack cheese spreads…Old Fashioned Gourmet. A tantalizing selection of upscale cheese flavor varieties, the Old Fashioned Gourmet line steps it up a notch for those who enjoy going beyond the ordinary.
LEARN MORE

We can't wait to hear from you.

Contact Us

Address:

650 Furnace St Mayville, WI 53050

Email:

Sales@oldfash.com

Phone:

920.387.4444